Saturday, February 9, 2013

Cop Killer, Christopher Dorner, and "John Brown's Body"



The murderously insane and quixotic quest that Christopher Dorner has embarked upon will mark him in history alongside a number of erstwhile madmen.  So, while I'm tracking the media...and the media are tracking the police...who are chaotically tracking Dorner, a melodic tune is echoing through my mind.  It's the well known tune, "Battle Hymn of the Republic."  But, the lyrics I hear are not those I so proudly and dutifully memorized in grade school.  The words are strangely different:

 
"Old John Brown’s body lies moldering in the grave,
While weep the sons of bondage whom he ventured all to save;
But tho he lost his life while struggling for the slave,
His soul is marching on."


Unknown to many, the tune now known as the "Battle Hymn of the Republic" was born "John Brown's Body" during the Civil War as a Union Army marching song.  In later years, the melody remained the same but the lyrics were changed to strike a more patriotic and conciliatory tone. It became President Lincoln's favorite song. But, history strongly suggests that the original song was meant to honor the "maniacal madman," John Brown.

On October 16, 1859, Brown, a white abolistionist, led 21 men on a raid of the federal arsenal at Harpers Ferry, Virginia. However, his plan to incite a slave revolt by arming them with weapons was thwarted by local farmers, militiamen, and U.S. Marines. Within a few days of the attack, most of Brown's men had been killed or captured.

Christopher Dorner, a former Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) officer and commissioned officer in the U.S. Navy, appears to be on a similarly horrific hazard to avenge the "racism" and "corruption" he alleges is rampant in the LAPD.

In a final "manifesto" published on Facebook prior to his killing spree, Dorner stated that the LAPD fired him in retaliation for protesting "racist" and "corrupt" departmental practices.  He alleges to have witnessed, reported and resisted practices of excessive use of force, use of the word, "nigger," abuse of the mentally ill, and the singing of "nazi youth songs." The LAPD repaid his good deeds, he says, by labeling him a "bully" and starting an internal affairs investigation of him.  Dorner states the only way to reclaim his reputation is by executing those who dispossessed him of it. So, he's killed three Los Angeles police officers...and counting.

Of course, this "manifesto" may simply be the mad ravings of a deranged and psychopathic killer attempting to rationalize his uncivilized behavior. But, the same was said of old John Brown.

Make no mistake, from what we know, John Brown's quest to free enslaved Africans was immensely more noble than Dorner's narcissistic quest for personal redemption. But, Dorner has couched his assailable adventure in the struggle for "justice." Justice, he says, for himself and other Los Angelenos who must submit to the authority of a "corrupt" police department.  In that VERY narrow sense alone, Dorner and Brown may occupy the same cabin on the train of justice. But, can such malodorous means ever justify the ends of justice....an eternal question? I believe the killing of innocent victims can seldom, if ever, be justified.

Could rapper "Ice T," a product of the Crenshaw district of Los Angeles, have envisioned Christoper Dorner when recording his prophetic and controversial cut, "Cop Killer?" "Hip-hop heads" and "hip-hopologist" alike are quizzically musing as the drama unfolds. Was the great Gil Scott-Heron visionary when he depicted cops "striding the city streets like robot gunslingers with gun butts and police shields?" Or, are America's PTSD stricken "chickens" limping home to lay a few rotten eggs? Another professional killer, trained by America, has come home to menace and stalk the streets of America.

.....John Brown was wounded, captured, moved to Charlestown, Virginia, tried and convicted of treason. Prior to sentencing, Brown addressed the court and said, ". . . . I believe to have interfered as I have done, . . . in behalf of His despised poor, was not wrong, but right. Now, if it be deemed necessary that I should forfeit my life for the furtherance of the ends of justice, and mingle my blood further with the blood of my children, and with the blood of millions in this slave country whose rights are disregarded by wicked, cruel, and unjust enactments, I submit: so let it be done."

John Brown was hanged on December 2, 1859.

His hanging popularized the phrase, "I'll be John Browned!"  I remember hearing my older relatives use that phrase.  The phrase means, "I'll be damned!" in recognition of Brown's certain damnation, or alternatively, to exclaim astonishment or amazement. For sure, Christopher Dorner will be "John Browned" in the most dire sense of the word.  Maybe by lethal injection, or by gas chamber, or by electric chair, or at the hands of the LAPD.  The point is, he WILL be "John Browned"....but, I won't be John Browned...not in the least.

While pondering the lyrics to "John Brown's Body," I'm saddened at the death of innocents and I grieve with their families.  And, upon his death, Dorner will surely be lip synching the Julia Ward Howe written lyrics to the "Battle Hymn of the Republic," "He hath sounded forth the trumpet which shall never call retreat...." the VIOLENCE IS MARCHING ON!!!!

Until we rendezvous...

Peace!!

7 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I appreciate the light connection to John Brown. Thanks for reminding me.

    As a more than 40 year resident of Los Angeles, it grieves me that a Christopher Dorner needs to exist. The LAPD has had ample time to correct it's relationship with people of color and women. The decades march on and the corrections do come but undeniably slow. I remember our last "two civil unrests" and the tensions caused by peoples' distrust of each others' perceived agendas. Interestingly, it didn't take groups of people to incite people to riot. There were no speeches, no leaders, just spontaneous responses to what people perceived as injustices.

    We, Los Angelenos, have a love hate relationship with LAPD, less friend, and more like a necessary stranger. Depending on your color, socioeconomic status, where you live, age or origin, your relationship with the LAPD can be easily plotted. For the brave souls who venture into the belly of the beast with good intentions as a career move, most end up changed. Three of my buddies made their passage there and only one made it past five years. All have moved on, presumably wiser, but definitely changed. Does racism, sexism, cronyism and corruption exist within the LAPD? Just google "LAPD consent decree" and pick a story for your answer. But the public doesn't really care. They don't care about "cops" and their drama. It only matters when that drama spills out onto their daily lives. For example, a side story of the two Latina women delivering newspapers at 2am in the morning near a house owned by someone on Dorner's hit list showed LAPD's response. Yeah, I'm sure in the dark any pickup truck looks like any other pickup truck but to unload nearly 50 rounds into the truck without even identifying yourself tells me they were ordered to John Brown the man. By the grace of God, the women survived. That's when people care, when they are affected. If everyone's injustice belongs to someone else, how can real progress be made?


    Do I suspect "civil unrest" should Dorner be John Browned? Doubtful, people see this the way the respond to a neighbor's family dispute, they eavesdrop but try to stay out of it. After all, they live next door. A little too uncomfortable for most.

    I abhor violence. I detest the slaughter of innocents. And yes, he's crossed a line from which there is no return, but I can't help thinking that this could have somehow been prevented if a cleaner, more tolerant, accepting LAPD existed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ticos, I really appreciate your well written and thoughtful comments. As a LA resident, your point of view is of utmost relevance. I sympathize with you and others in the community who may have suffered indignities at the hands of LAPD.

      It seems inevitable that the LAPD will assist Dorner in meeting his death, but hopefully the killing will end...all the killing, all the corruption, all the racism. LA deserves policemen/women (former and current) who will serve and protect; not stalk and menace.

      Be Safe, Ticos! Thank you for reading my humble blogpost, and feel free to comment again.

      Peace!

      Delete
  3. Although you are physically slient, your written thoughts are sounding off loudly. I can only say, "YES, BUT NOW WHAT.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Donna, you are too kind! Once again, I appreciate you comments. I will be speaking on a number of interesting topics in the future...stay tuned. I have one question for you? Can I get a retweet? :-)

    Take care,

    Peace!!

    ReplyDelete

  5. I really like your blog. I find it very interesting that you deal with current topics in an engaging and entertaining way and that you make connections to historical events that bear similarities or parallels. I really appreciate that perspective because I believe that history does repeat herself; even tough, the underlying similarities may be disguised by different characters, circumstances, place and time.

    Here are my comments to this post 'Cop Killer, Christopher Dorner, and "John Brown's Body"'.
    I like and agree with the thoughtful comments posted by the Ticos, the LA Resident.

    Everything reproduces after its kind. I cannot side with Dorner, but neither can I side with the LAPD if the allegations are true. We must be aware that because of the inescapable Universal Law of cause and effect, Karma, "You reap what you sow",or "Chickens coming home to roost", every Evil we perpetrate, support or silently condone will come back multiplied. Any of us could be the intended target or a collateral damage. I do not approve of Dorner's method, but no Dorners will need to exists, if there was no violence in the form of abuse of power, blind discrimination, senseless prejudices and brutal racism.

    The lines have been drawn and continue to be drawn. Some for Dorner, some for LAPD. Justice is not the same as revenge.... But could revenge ever lead to justice?


    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you so much for your insightful comments, Damaris!! I really appreciate your sentiments. You are correct; the law of karma, in most cases, is inescapable.

    For those who are religious, Dorner is "walking across Hell on a spider web." For the non-religious, he is simply psychopathic.

    But, LAPD cannot escape its karma either!!

    Take care and much love, Damaris!!

    ReplyDelete